Stellman is a three time All-PAC selection. He earned All-PAC Honorable Mention, Second Team All-PAC and finally First Team All-PAC as a senior. During his career the quarterback passed for 5,328 yards which is the 4th most in Thomas More program history at the time of his induction. He also tallied 399 completions and is 24th in the career scoring list with 104 points. Stellman holds the single season record at Thomas More for passing touchdowns with 26 in his senior season.